You’re craving that classic cozy taste of pumpkin pie, but your gut, your ethics, or your dietary choices are like, “Not today, butter and sugar!” Whether you’re vegan, gluten-free, dairy-free, or trying to avoid refined sugar, it can feel like dessert just gave you the cold shoulder. But guess what? You don’t have to miss out. Stick around, because I’m about to walk you through a ridiculously good pumpkin pie recipe that checks all the boxes—without tasting like cardboard or sadness. I’ll even toss in a few pro tips, some links to bomb breakfast ideas like vegan gluten-free pancakes, and keep it super real the whole way through.

What Makes This Pumpkin Pie So Special?

Look, I’ve tried a lot of “healthy” pies that ended up tasting like disappointment in a crust.
So I went full mad-scientist in the kitchen. After too many test runs (and a few emotional breakdowns), I finally nailed it:

• Vegan (zero eggs, zero dairy)
  
• Gluten-free (yup, even the crust)
  
• Dairy-free (no weird milks here)
  
• Refined sugar-free (bye-bye, sugar crash)
  

And the texture? Smooth as silk. The flavor? Pumpkin spice heaven.
You won’t even notice it’s healthy. And trust me, your guests won’t even believe it’s true.

The Crust: No Sad Crumbles Here

Alright, let’s be real. Most gluten-free crusts either fall apart or taste like someone crushed up rice cakes and prayed for flavor.
Not this one.

You only need a few staples:

• Almond flour – adds richness and a buttery texture
  
• Coconut flour – for structure (and that subtle sweetness)
  
• Maple syrup – our plant-based sweet fix
  
• Coconut oil – keeps it all together, plus that smooth flavor
  

Wanna save time? You can grab some almond flour and organic coconut flour, no problem,

Mix it up, press it into a pie dish, and bake it for about 10 minutes. Easy. Don’t overthink it.

The Filling: Sweet, Creamy, No Nonsense

Now comes the best part of this pie—the rich, flavorful filling.

What you’ll need:

• Canned pumpkin puree – not pie filling. Keep it clean.
  
• Coconut cream – for that thick, dreamy texture
  
• Maple or date syrup—sweet, but still keeping it clean.

• Pumpkin pie spice – you can buy or make it yourself
  
• Arrowroot starch – to hold it together (like cornstarch, but better)
  

Bonus points if you grab a good-quality coconut cream like this—it makes all the difference. Trust me, I’ve tried the watery ones. Disaster.

Just toss it all in a bowl, whisk it ‘til it’s smooth, pour it over your pre-baked crust, and bake again until it sets (about 45–50 minutes). Let it cool fully before slicing—this is not a “cut it while hot” situation unless you want a pumpkin puddle.

What To Expect: Flavor, Texture, and Zero Regret

That first bite hits you with cinnamon, nutmeg, and all the warm pumpkin goodness.
. The crust? Soft but structured. The filling? Smooth like a dream.
You’re not sitting there thinking, “This is good… for being vegan.”
You’re just like, “Yo, pass me another slice.”

This pie plays well with others too. Got a brunch spread planned? Pair it with some gluten-free oat waffles or low FODMAP French toast, and you’re winning.

My Moment (And a Story)

Okay—confession time. When I first whipped up this pie, I took it to a family dinner.
Didn’t say a word about it being vegan or gluten-free. My uncle, who literally brings bacon to vegan potlucks just to “add flavor,” devoured it.
He had two slices. Then he asked if I bought it from Whole Foods.
When I told him it was homemade and dairy-free? Man looked personally attacked.
That’s how you know it’s good.

Tips To Make It Even Better

• Chill it overnight. The spices mellow beautifully, and it firms up like a dream.
  
• Top it with coconut whipped cream or even some crushed nuts if you’re feelin’ fancy.
  
• Don’t skimp on the spice. Seriously. Bland pie is a crime.
  

 Want More Vegan & Refined Sugar-Free Goodness?

If you’re all about that clean dessert life, don’t stop at just one pie.

Take a look at Bakerita — it’s full of easy, gluten-free, dairy-free, and refined sugar-free recipes that genuinely taste delicious.

It’s like dessert without the drama.

Or if you’ve got a major sweet tooth (same here), treat yourself to Sweet Vegan Treats—it’s loaded with brownies, blondies, cookies, and all the plant-based sweet things you didn’t know you needed.

Real talk? These books are total game changers if you’re ready to ditch the sugar crash but keep dessert in your life.

Final Thoughts: This Ain’t Just a “Healthy Alternative”

This right here is your ultimate pumpkin pie, no questions asked. The best part? It’s totally vegan, gluten-free, dairy-free, and skips the refined sugar. Whether you’ve got dietary restrictions or just want to feel a little better after dessert (instead of falling into a sugar coma), this pie delivers.

Want more clean and cozy dessert ideas? You might also love this healthy carrot cake—it’s basically pumpkin pie’s cousin with a wild side.

The Coziest Pumpkin Pie Recipe (Vegan, Gluten-Free, Dairy-Free, Refined Sugar-Free)

Tarek Rakhiess, May 15, 2025May 15, 2025

You’re craving that classic cozy taste of pumpkin pie, but your gut, your ethics, or your dietary choices are like, “Not today, butter and sugar!” Whether you’re vegan, gluten-free, dairy-free, or trying to avoid refined sugar, it can feel like dessert just gave you the cold shoulder. But guess what? You don’t have to miss out. Stick around, because I’m about to walk you through a ridiculously good pumpkin pie recipe that checks all the boxes—without tasting like cardboard or sadness. I’ll even toss in a few pro tips, some links to bomb breakfast ideas like vegan gluten-free pancakes, and keep it super real the whole way through.

Table of Contents

What Makes This Pumpkin Pie So Special?

Look, I’ve tried a lot of “healthy” pies that ended up tasting like disappointment in a crust.
So I went full mad-scientist in the kitchen. After too many test runs (and a few emotional breakdowns), I finally nailed it:

• Vegan (zero eggs, zero dairy)
  
• Gluten-free (yup, even the crust)
  
• Dairy-free (no weird milks here)
  
• Refined sugar-free (bye-bye, sugar crash)
  

And the texture? Smooth as silk. The flavor? Pumpkin spice heaven.
You won’t even notice it’s healthy. And trust me, your guests won’t even believe it’s true.

The Crust: No Sad Crumbles Here

Alright, let’s be real. Most gluten-free crusts either fall apart or taste like someone crushed up rice cakes and prayed for flavor.
Not this one.

You only need a few staples:

• Almond flour – adds richness and a buttery texture
  
• Coconut flour – for structure (and that subtle sweetness)
  
• Maple syrup – our plant-based sweet fix
  
• Coconut oil – keeps it all together, plus that smooth flavor
  

Wanna save time? You can grab some almond flour and organic coconut flour, no problem,

Mix it up, press it into a pie dish, and bake it for about 10 minutes. Easy. Don’t overthink it.

The Filling: Sweet, Creamy, No Nonsense

Now comes the best part of this pie—the rich, flavorful filling.

What you’ll need:

• Canned pumpkin puree – not pie filling. Keep it clean.
  
• Coconut cream – for that thick, dreamy texture
  
• Maple or date syrup—sweet, but still keeping it clean.

• Pumpkin pie spice – you can buy or make it yourself
  
• Arrowroot starch – to hold it together (like cornstarch, but better)
  

Bonus points if you grab a good-quality coconut cream like this—it makes all the difference. Trust me, I’ve tried the watery ones. Disaster.

Just toss it all in a bowl, whisk it ‘til it’s smooth, pour it over your pre-baked crust, and bake again until it sets (about 45–50 minutes). Let it cool fully before slicing—this is not a “cut it while hot” situation unless you want a pumpkin puddle.

What To Expect: Flavor, Texture, and Zero Regret

That first bite hits you with cinnamon, nutmeg, and all the warm pumpkin goodness.
. The crust? Soft but structured. The filling? Smooth like a dream.
You’re not sitting there thinking, “This is good… for being vegan.”
You’re just like, “Yo, pass me another slice.”

This pie plays well with others too. Got a brunch spread planned? Pair it with some gluten-free oat waffles or low FODMAP French toast, and you’re winning.

My Moment (And a Story)

Okay—confession time. When I first whipped up this pie, I took it to a family dinner.
Didn’t say a word about it being vegan or gluten-free. My uncle, who literally brings bacon to vegan potlucks just to “add flavor,” devoured it.
He had two slices. Then he asked if I bought it from Whole Foods.
When I told him it was homemade and dairy-free? Man looked personally attacked.
That’s how you know it’s good.

Tips To Make It Even Better

• Chill it overnight. The spices mellow beautifully, and it firms up like a dream.
  
• Top it with coconut whipped cream or even some crushed nuts if you’re feelin’ fancy.
  
• Don’t skimp on the spice. Seriously. Bland pie is a crime.
  

 Want More Vegan & Refined Sugar-Free Goodness?

If you’re all about that clean dessert life, don’t stop at just one pie.

Take a look at Bakerita — it’s full of easy, gluten-free, dairy-free, and refined sugar-free recipes that genuinely taste delicious.

It’s like dessert without the drama.

Or if you’ve got a major sweet tooth (same here), treat yourself to Sweet Vegan Treats—it’s loaded with brownies, blondies, cookies, and all the plant-based sweet things you didn’t know you needed.

Real talk? These books are total game changers if you’re ready to ditch the sugar crash but keep dessert in your life.

Final Thoughts: This Ain’t Just a “Healthy Alternative”

This right here is your ultimate pumpkin pie, no questions asked. The best part? It’s totally vegan, gluten-free, dairy-free, and skips the refined sugar. Whether you’ve got dietary restrictions or just want to feel a little better after dessert (instead of falling into a sugar coma), this pie delivers.

Want more clean and cozy dessert ideas? You might also love this healthy carrot cake—it’s basically pumpkin pie’s cousin with a wild side.

this post may contain affiliate links which means I may earn a small commission from affiliate links at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products we trust and believe add value. Your support helps us keep creating helpful content—thank you! for full details

Gluten Free recipes Vegan Weight loss recipes Pumpkin Pie RecipeRefined Sugar-Free dessertvegan gluten free dessert